makadeade
home about archive (feed)

The harmful role of Critical Role

Published: November 19th 2026 (week 47 of 2026) under rpg

It was not only Critical Role's fault that expectations around role-playing games changed, but the show is the epitome of the problem.

At this point I have been running role-playing games for decades. The first one I have played, way back in the early 2000s, was Wiedźmin: Gra Wyobraźni ie, "Witcher: a Game of Imagination", an old Polish game. Soon afterwards, my mother bought me a Dungeons and Dragons starter set for 3.5e and that was it. I was hooked on tabletop fantasy role-playing games forever.

However, I soon faced a few problems.

The starter set that I had only had four 10x10 dungeon boards, a dozen miniatures, and set of dice, and a short introduction to the rules of the game. I saw rulebooks on the shelves in bookstores, but they were, for a 10-year-old boy, prohibitively expensive. The miniature sets were ruinously expensive. The only part of the hobby that was affordable were the cheap plastic single-coloured dice.

Given these constraints, there were only two options:

  1. give up, because I can't afford the hobby
  2. buy dice and create everything else myself

I chose the second option, and it led me down the path of designing systems, writing adventures, and running games. There was simply no other way. After some time I managed to obtain the Polish translation of the 3.5e Player's Handbook, but that was it. Everything else was imagination, creativity, and love for the hobby. Keep those three things in mind.

A decade or so later

I have tried various published systems. I have run published adventures and ones that I wrote myself, and ran them for both friends at home and strangers at conventions. I have introduced new people to the hobby, and I have seen people leave it.

Throughout all these years I have never felt the need to use extravagant props, engage in theatre (do voices, dress up, etc), or have a separate specially-lit room just for playing the games. Then, I think after Wizards of the Coast published the 5th edition of Dungeons and Dragons, something changed. I noticed people's expectations shifted, and suddenly you, as the game master, were expected to have the props and do the voices.

I continued doing my thing, because you live and let live, right? If someone wants to engage in the hobby in a different way than I do, it is their prerogative, and let them do whatever floats their boat.

In the meantime, I have even purchased some tools to use at the games I run. The first was a dry-erase mat with a hex grid, which, as it turns out, is an awesome thing to have. The second was a set of small wooden "guys", like the ones you use for traditional board games, which also turned out to be a great thing to have.

The wooden guys

Then, I was running a game at a local library. There were other game masters too, since it was an event organised by an RPG club I was part of at the time. I overheard that one of the GMs forgot their miniatures, so, ever the helpful guy that I am, I offered to lend them some of my wooden guys. I had more than enough for the adventure I was running, so I could share my "wealth".

The look of bafflement and disgust on their face once they saw what I was offering was eye-opening. The other eye-opening thing was that they would rather play without any miniatures, than play using the simple, cheap, wooden ones I offered them.

I say it was an eye-opening event, because suddenly I started seeing similar attitude more often. People playing with elaborate boards, complete with little walls, trees, environmental details, and whatnots; the game masters separating themselves from the players with screens (I still fail to see the appeal of those); or carrying rulebooks and pre-written adventures in their backpack.

And what do I bring? A simple hex grid, two dozen wooden guys, some dice, the core rulebook for Warhammer Fantasy Roleplay (because Dungeons and Dragons has jumped the shark with the 5th edition), and a single A4 sheet with the adventure I have written.

I don't know, maybe it's my internal le misérable speaking, but... I think that is enough. Why would I spend €50 on something when I can spend €15 and use my imagination, in a literal game of imagination? Isn't it the whole point of the game that you pretend to be an elf/rogue/dwarf/sorcerer/human fighting an imaginary orc/necromancer/skeleton/kobold/cultist in a place/dungeon/jungle that only exists in your head?

When did what the game looks like start to be more important than what the game is about? To me it is the same level of shallow as thinking that a romantic relationship is only about how hot your partner is; or thinking that friendship is measured in how many pints of beer someone buys you, not in how much you can trust and rely on them. Visible vs invisible qualities.

Old man yells at cloud

Old man yells at cloud, sure, but it looks like money starts gating a hobby that one used to be able to engage in for essentially gratis. I was not able to afford the books and the miniatures, but I was still able to develop love and passion for the hobby. Now it looks like you need a buy-in at the table.

The harmful role

This brings me back to the critisism of Critical Role.

Of course, everyone makes their own decisions. Of course, everyone is responsible for their actions. Of course, everyone can choose to do, or do not, whatever they like.

But we are not lone islands, and our perceptions and expectations are shaped by what happens around us. And I do not think the cultural notoriety that Critical Role reached has had no influence on how people, especially those new to the hobby, perceive what role-playing games are about. It just looks like they are not about adventures in an imaginary world, but rather a staged experience for the benefit and entertainment of the players.

If the entry point is not a book shop and a couple cheap dice, but a professionally produced show with professional actors assuming roles of the players, then I can see why one would be underwhelmed by the relative lack of intensity and polish of the real thing.

This is actually a similar problem to the one presented by porn.

If your expectations of real-life sex are shaped by what you have seen on PornHub, you are in for a hell of a shock.

Same thing with RPGs. If your expectations of a real-life session are shaped by what you have seen on Critical Role's YouTube, you are in for a hell of a shock. Or lack of shock.

Unless you are able to distinguish an illusion professionally produced for your entertainment from the real world that is in no way, shape, or form produced for you, you are going to have a bad time.

The way I see it, the pornification of expectations of role-playing games has damaged the hobby.

Tags

Earlier under rpg: "The Importance of Terrain"

Earlier under porn: Inside the porn industry’s revolt against tech rules

Earlier under money: A new French tax on gigabytes

Previous: This fucken blog!